Being a member of a youth group at Church will teach you a lot of things. You may (hopefully) learn about the Christian faith. You may learn about friendship, romance, or conflict resolution. Maybe you’ll even witness for the first time that yes, farts can indeed be ignited into flames (and it’s the funniest thing I’ve ever seen).
What you’ll definitely witness and likely take part in, however, is the time-honored practice of the Christian Knock-Off. You see, we Christians don’t like to be original. We’re rip-off Jews, what are we supposed to do?
We take what the “secular” world produces, and we say “Hey, that’s super rad! But since it’s secular it’s probably going to hell along with everyone at MSNBC and Stephanie Meyer. We should make our own version of it so that we can make sure it goes to heaven too!” From music to movies to t-shirts, if you make it, we’ll take it, throw it in the washer a bunch of times so it shrinks and fades, draw a cross on it with a Sharpie, and sell it at LifeWay.
Remember back in the day when YouTube exploded like Octomom’s v…oracious appetite for childbearing (and life-ruining)? Music videos became relevant for the first time since MTV decided to change its programming strategy from “Music” to “whatever sucks and will destroy happiness and souls,” talentless pubescent zit-bags with webcams all over the world found a way to express their talentless pubescence with ease, and the Motion Picture Association of America and the Recording Industry Association of America found a whole new way to satisfy their hunger for all things related to lawsuits and making everyone hate them. It was a beautiful thing.
Fresh off of the loss of Jessica Simpson to 98 Degrees, Evangelicals needed us some beauty. Rather than, you know, participating in the normal trend with the rest of the world, we made “GodTube.” It’s like YouTube, but it’s for God. So only God can use it. Or something. Anyway it’s Christian, so tell your pastor.
Go back a few years before that. Remember when boy bands started tearing up our hearts? Anyway, we Christians lamentably had a boy band all of our own. The sonic equivalent of religiously motivated castration, plusOne – whose name signifies absolutely nothing except a possible reference to a wedding invitation – hit the scene in 2000. Their line-up consisted of 5 moderately-attractive-but-fantastically-moral Christian dudes singing songs about Jesus. Which makes a lot of sense, you know, to sing songs about Jesus using a genre that is known for its romantic songs marketed to pre-pubescent girls. Somehow I feel dirty, having just thought about the whole thing.
What about reality TV? You just cringed, didn’t you? You know what’s coming, just like my toilet knows what’s coming after a meal at Chipotle. Get it?! Crap. The joke is that it’s crap. One Christian reality TV show is called “The Uprising.” I said “one” on purpose. There’s more than one, but because I love you and this hurts me more than it hurts you (seriously) I’m only going to talk about this one. The central conflict of this particular show centers around whether or not a few pro skateboarders will decide to be “born again.” I’m fairly sure that will give people more delusions about God than anything Richard Dawkins could write.
Ever heard of the blog “Stuff White People Like”? It’s pretty funny. An original idea. Wasn’t long before the Christian “me too!” version popped up as “Things Christians Like.” It’s pretty funny, but can we really be proud of a good imitation? Thank God everyone else keeps having original ideas, otherwise we’d be stuck with Carmen and the PowerTeam.
I’m not going to even mention every single ridiculous Christian t-shirts you can still purchase at your local Christian bookstore. Those go without saying. I’ll mention an all-star though:
How are people supposed to trust that our faith is relevant when our art and culture is not? Can we be “not of this world” and the “salt of the earth” without having what amounts to the store-brand version of secular culture? Only Kirk Cameron really knows. Speaking of which, if you’ll please excuse me, I’m going to finish writing a letter to Kirk Cameron about my script for a Christian vampire flick called “Sondown.”
Popularity: 11% [?]



November 30th, 2009 at 2:03 am
Man, I completely forgot this sort of thing still existed. In my mind that was a Christian 90s fad. I guess that’s what happens when you move to an urban area…or to the Pacific Northwest…and join a mainline protestant church…or all three. I’d have to drive probably 60 minutes to find a true fundagelical.
November 30th, 2009 at 2:05 am
Conor, this is hilarious!
I want you to get your butt to Aquire the Fire as soon as you can, Let Go, and Let God, ok? Once you let go, merch is on the floor..Read this and cringe you bunch of goof ball youth pastors. Your kids only think you’re cool because they are 14, and not allowed to be anywhere else on Wednesday night then your youth group. When the swelling goes down, get on your knees and ask the Lord for some originality, and then…breath… actually do it. I dare you. You may begin to have some seniors show up.
Great job Conor. Get your butt down to South Tx. I owe you a bohemian black.
December 1st, 2009 at 1:48 am
It’s a really sad thing to see. And I only wish it was recent, but it’s really what Christianity’s outreach methods have been based around for…good two millenia, come to think of it
My personal favourite is the pop song with reworked lyrics. Sick of the same old acoustic guitar chords one after the other with vaguely Christian loving lyrics? Get a pop-rock song (that’s generally pretty tasteful to start with) and throw a load of ‘Jesus’ and ‘Lord’ and ‘You rock!’ in there. Hey presto, new anthem for the next five minutes of Christian CD sales.
December 1st, 2009 at 5:01 pm
“rip-off Jews.” fantastic. “store-brand,” indeed.
December 9th, 2009 at 9:51 pm
wait a minute, isn’t this blog just a christian knock-off of the onion.
December 9th, 2009 at 11:25 pm
Nope. Have you ever read The Onion? I could understand the comment if you had posted it on an article that was in the “fake news” format, which we certainly employ sometimes. But this isn’t even close.
This is your second negative comment on our site. I’m sorry you don’t like what we do. I’m not sure what it is that you have against us, and I’m not sure it matters. Keep posting negative comments if you want. We’re going to keep doing what we’re doing.
And yeah man, we’re Christians writing humor. Sorry that pisses you off so much.
December 15th, 2009 at 11:45 am
“Got Faith?” t-shirts are the worst.
Have you seen the South Park episode about Christian bands? Dead on.
December 16th, 2009 at 3:26 pm
You should read “Rapture Ready: Adventures in the Parallel Universe of Christian Pop Culture” by the non-Christian Daniel Radosh. Instead of making fun of Christians he tries to see the best intentions, but he also does see the problems and rediculousness of some of these various Christian products and “knock-offs.”
December 22nd, 2009 at 11:59 am
not kidding at all – I have actually been to a plusOne concert.
January 25th, 2010 at 11:43 am
BTW, it’s Stephenie Meyer.